Skip to content

ART Therapy vs EMDR: Key Differences Between Accelerated Resolution Therapy and EMDR

Accelerated resolution therapy (ART) and EMDR both use side-to-side eye movements to take the charge out of traumatic memories. EMDR is older, follows eight phases and has far more research behind it. ART grew out of EMDR, is more directive, uses image rescripting and is often delivered in fewer sessions, but it has much less research so far.

Therapies & treatmentUpdated Nov 9, 20268 min read

If this is a medical emergency, call 911. For a mental health or suicide crisis, call or text 988.

  • The Joint Commission Gold Seal of Approval
  • Licensed by the Utah Department of Health and Human Services, license F23-98436
  • Verified by Psychology Today
  • LegitScript Certified
Table of contents
  1. What is accelerated resolution therapy (ART)?
  2. What is EMDR therapy?
  3. ART vs EMDR: how do they compare?
  4. What does the research say about ART?
  5. What conditions are ART and EMDR used for?
  6. Are there side effects of ART or EMDR?
  7. How do you choose between ART and EMDR?
  8. What else is used in modern trauma therapy?
  9. How Corner Canyon uses ART and EMDR
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Sources

Key takeaways

  • Accelerated resolution therapy (ART) and EMDR both use side-to-side eye movements to take the charge out of traumatic memories, and neither requires you to describe the trauma out loud or do homework.1,4
  • EMDR was introduced in 1987, follows eight phases and is one of the three trauma-focused talk therapies the National Center for PTSD lists as working best for PTSD.1,3,6
  • ART is newer and more directive. Its key step is voluntary image replacement, and in its main randomized trial, 57 service members and veterans finished treatment in about 3.7 sessions on average.4,5
  • ART and EMDR haven't been compared head to head in a large trial, so neither has been shown to work better than the other.4
  • At Corner Canyon, EMDR-trained therapists use EMDR mostly in individual therapy, alongside accelerated resolution therapy and IFS chosen to fit each adult's plan.

Accelerated resolution therapy (ART) is a newer form of psychotherapy that grew out of the older, more established EMDR (eye movement desensitization and reprocessing). Both use side-to-side eye movements to reprocess painful memories, and in both you don’t have to describe the trauma in detail. Some people even call ART “EMDR on steroids.”

The two differ in how sessions run, how directive the therapist is, how long treatment tends to take and how much research supports each one. This guide explains what each therapy is, compares ART vs EMDR side by side and offers some practical questions for choosing between them.

ART is not art therapy

"ART therapy" here means accelerated resolution therapy, an eye-movement trauma therapy. It's different from art therapy, which uses drawing, painting and other creative work to express feelings.

What to expect when you call admissions

Dominique, an admissions counselor, on taking the first step and letting the team help.

What is accelerated resolution therapy (ART)?

ART is a brief, eye-movement-based psychotherapy. Sets of back-and-forth eye movements, which many people find calming, are combined with a technique called voluntary memory or image replacement. ART relies heavily on imagination: rescripting distressing events and images is one of its key elements4.

In a session, the therapist asks you to picture a distressing event, or a metaphor that stands for it, and helps you notice and settle the body sensations that come up. You don’t have to talk about the content.

Then the therapist guides you to replace the distressing images with ones you choose. The aim is to change how the memory is stored, so it no longer sets off strong physical and emotional reactions, even though you still remember the facts of what happened.

ART draws on EMDR and several other approaches, but it has its own procedures. It’s often described as including the elements considered most important in trauma-focused therapy: exposure, cognitive restructuring, relaxation skills, education about trauma, organizing memories and directly targeting negative emotions4.

The three phases of ART

ART is usually delivered over a short course of sessions:

  1. Phase 1: AssessmentHistory, current symptoms and what you want to work on, usually in the first one to three sessions.
  2. Phase 2: The ART protocolEye movements plus voluntary image replacement, guiding the memory from distress toward relief and change.
  3. Phase 3: Follow-upReviewing what's changed and whether other memories or problems would benefit from more work.

What is EMDR therapy?

EMDR was introduced in 1987 as a treatment for PTSD and has grown into a full therapy approach with its own protocols3. It’s based on the adaptive information processing model: the idea that the mind, like the body, moves naturally toward healing, and that symptoms come from memories that were never fully processed3.

In EMDR, you hold a distressing memory in mind, along with the thoughts and body sensations that come with it, while paying attention to a back-and-forth movement or sound, such as the therapist’s moving finger, a light or alternating tones1.

The bilateral movement helps you stay in the present while the brain processes the past. Over time, the memory becomes less distressing, and you build more positive beliefs about yourself. “Processing” an experience doesn’t mean talking about it. It means making sense of it and no longer being thrown by it1.

EMDR is highly structured, with eight phases. Not every phase happens in every session, but each one contributes to the result2. Our walkthrough of the 8 phases of EMDR explains each step. Sessions usually last 60 to 90 minutes2. Beyond PTSD, EMDR has been applied to phobias, anxiety and other problems linked to distressing memories2.

What they say is what they do.

RonCorner Canyon team · Corner Canyon video

ART vs EMDR: how do they compare?

Here’s a side-by-side comparison of accelerated resolution therapy and EMDR.

ART EMDR
Origins Newer; built on EMDR Introduced in 1987
Core idea Rescript disturbing images Reprocess stored memories
Structure 3 phases 8 phases
Typical sessions About 3–4 in the main trial 3–6 per memory; 8–12+ for complex trauma
Therapist style Directive Less directive
Talking about details Not required Not required
Homework No No
Research base Small but growing Large; guideline-recommended

What they have in common

  • Both use sets of eye movements while you hold a memory in mind.
  • Neither requires you to describe the trauma out loud1.
  • Neither requires homework between sessions1.
  • Both are brief compared with many talk therapies.
  • Both aim for the memory to lose its emotional and physical charge, not to be erased.

Where they differ

  • Technique. ART’s signature step is voluntary image replacement: you consciously swap distressing images for new ones. EMDR focuses on an image, a negative belief and the feelings that go with it while letting the mind move freely during bilateral stimulation, then strengthens a positive belief.
  • Therapist role. ART is more directive; the therapist guides you through set steps. In EMDR, the therapist follows where your mind goes between sets.
  • Length. In the main ART trial, people finished in an average of 3.7 sessions5. EMDR usually takes three to six sessions for a single disturbing memory and eight to 12 or more for complex or long-term trauma2. A typical full course of EMDR for PTSD is about three months of weekly sessions1.
  • Evidence. EMDR is one of the most effective treatments for PTSD and is one of the three trauma-focused talk therapies the National Center for PTSD lists as working best, along with cognitive processing therapy and prolonged exposure1,6. ART’s research is still limited.
  • Availability. EMDR has many more trained therapists, so it’s easier to find.

My experience at Corner Canyon to put it simply, was life changing. The program gave me a structure to set a solid foundation for my life outside of treatment.

Sav H.Former client · Google review
Explore care at Corner Canyon
See all programs

What does the research say about ART?

ART is one of the newer trauma therapies, so it has the least research of the two. A 2017 review described ART as promising, effective and efficient, but noted that the evidence mainly consisted of one randomized controlled trial and two larger cohort studies, and called for more high-quality trials4.

That randomized trial included 57 U.S. service members and veterans with combat-related PTSD, most of whom had already tried PTSD treatment. ART was delivered in about 3.7 sessions, 94% of participants completed it, and PTSD, depression, anxiety and guilt symptoms dropped significantly more than in the comparison group, with gains holding at three months. Serious side effects weren’t reported5.

Those results are encouraging, but one trial in one population isn’t the same as decades of research. ART and EMDR haven’t been compared head to head in a large trial, so no one can say yet that one works better than the other.

What conditions are ART and EMDR used for?

Both therapies were built for trauma, and that’s where most of their research sits. EMDR is mainly used for PTSD, and clinicians also use it for anxiety disorders such as generalized anxiety disorder, panic disorder, phobias and social anxiety, for depression and for dissociative disorders2.

The research for those uses is thinner than for PTSD, so a careful assessment comes first.

ART research so far has mostly involved PTSD, and its main trial focused on service members and veterans with combat-related trauma5. Whether it helps other conditions as much is still an open question.

Are there side effects of ART or EMDR?

Both are generally considered low-risk, but working with traumatic memories can stir things up for a while. In EMDR, you may feel uncomfortable while you focus on trauma-related memories or beliefs. These feelings are usually brief, and people tend to feel better as they keep going1.

The most common negative effects of EMDR are upsetting thoughts or feelings between sessions, and your therapist can help you know what to expect2. In the main ART trial, no serious side effects were reported, and 94% of participants finished treatment5.

A few things make the days between sessions easier:

  • Use your coping skills. EMDR starts by teaching coping skills before memory work, so you have tools ready1.
  • Tell your therapist. Strong reactions between sessions are useful information for pacing the next one.
  • Keep your routine steady. Regular sleep, meals and movement help a stirred-up nervous system settle.
  • Know your crisis options. If you have thoughts of suicide, call or text 988, or call 911 if you’re in danger.

How do you choose between ART and EMDR?

Both are reasonable options for trauma, and the therapist often matters as much as the method. Questions worth thinking about:

  • Evidence: Would you feel more confident in the therapy with the longer research record (EMDR), or are you open to a newer approach with promising early results (ART)?
  • Style: Do you prefer a therapist who guides each step closely, or more room for your mind to wander and connect things?
  • Time: Is a shorter course important to you right now?
  • Availability: Is a trained therapist for either one near you, and covered by your plan?
  • Referral: Has a therapist who knows your history recommended one?

If you have complex trauma, dissociation or a history of feeling overwhelmed in therapy, either method may start with a stabilization phase so you have coping skills in place before working on memories. A good trauma therapist will explain how they’ll pace the work.

What else is used in modern trauma therapy?

ART and EMDR sit within a wider set of trauma therapies. The approaches with the strongest evidence for PTSD are trauma-focused talk therapies: cognitive processing therapy, EMDR and prolonged exposure, which usually last about 8 to 16 sessions6.

Newer or complementary methods, such as ART, internal family systems, brainspotting and body-based or creative therapies, are often used alongside them, matched to the person rather than used as a one-size-fits-all plan. Our post on CBT vs CPT compares two of the talk therapies.

Inside our Fort Street house in Draper

A short tour of one of our residential homes, where clients live, eat and do much of their therapy.

How Corner Canyon uses ART and EMDR

At Corner Canyon Health Centers in Draper, Utah, trauma therapy happens mostly in individual sessions: twice a week in residential care, weekly in PHP and every other week in IOP.

Our EMDR therapy is provided by EMDR-trained therapists, including Sara Sorenson, LCMHC, a certified EMDR therapist, and is sometimes used in group as well. Accelerated resolution therapy is also part of how we treat trauma, with internal family systems (IFS) and other approaches chosen to fit your plan.

We also offer creative art therapy as part of our experiential program, which is easy to mix up with ART. If you’re wondering which trauma therapy might fit you, our admissions team can talk it through and explain how your treatment team would decide.

Frequently asked questions

Is ART better than EMDR?

Neither has been shown to be better than the other, because they haven't been compared head to head in a large trial. EMDR has far more research and is recommended in major PTSD guidelines. ART is newer and promising, with early studies showing results in few sessions.

Is ART therapy the same as art therapy?

They're different therapies. ART (accelerated resolution therapy) is an eye-movement-based trauma therapy. Art therapy is a creative therapy that uses drawing, painting or other art-making to express and process feelings. They share a name but work in completely different ways.

Do you have to talk about your trauma in ART or EMDR?

Not in detail. In both, you bring the memory to mind, but you don't have to describe it out loud. That's one reason some people who have struggled with talk-heavy therapy find these approaches easier.

How many sessions does ART take compared to EMDR?

In the main ART trial, people completed treatment in about 3.7 sessions on average. EMDR often takes three to six sessions for a single memory and eight to 12 or more for complex or long-term trauma. Your own number depends on what you're working through.

Can you do ART and EMDR together?

Some therapists trained in both use them at different points in treatment, depending on the memory and how you respond. It's a decision to make with your therapist rather than mixing them on your own.

Share this article

This article is for general education and doesn’t replace an individual medical or clinical evaluation. Everyone’s situation is different; a conversation with our team is the fastest way to know what applies to you.

If you or someone you care about is in immediate danger, call 911. For a mental health or suicide crisis, call or text 988.

Sources

The research and guidelines cited on this page. Numbers match the references in the text, and links open the original source.

6 sources cited

  1. 12026
    Department of Veterans Affairs, National Center for PTSDU.S · Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) for PTSD. PTSD: National Center for PTSDRead the sourceptsd.va.gov
  2. 22022
    EMDR Therapy: What It Is, Procedure and EffectivenessCleveland Clinic · Cleveland ClinicRead the sourcemy.clevelandclinic.org
  3. 32021
    The Structure of EMDR Therapy: A Guide for the TherapistHase M · Frontiers in PsychologyRead the sourcedoi.org
  4. 42017
    Accelerated Resolution Therapy (ART): a Review and Research to DateWaits W, Marumoto M, Weaver J · Current Psychiatry ReportsRead the sourcedoi.org
  5. 52013
    Randomized Controlled Trial of Accelerated Resolution Therapy (ART) for Symptoms of Combat-Related Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)Kip KE, Rosenzweig L, Hernandez DF, et al · Military MedicineRead the sourcedoi.org
  6. 62026
    Department of Veterans Affairs, National Center for PTSDU.S · PTSD Treatment Basics. PTSD: National Center for PTSDRead the sourceptsd.va.gov

Check my insurance coverage

100% confidential · No commitment required

Insurance card photos (optional, speeds verification up)

Or call (801) 383-0810. See our Privacy Policy and Notice of Privacy Practices.

Know what you’d pay before you decide

We work with most PPO plans that include out-of-network benefits. Our admissions team checks your benefits for free and explains your costs before you decide.

PPO plans with out-of-network benefitsUsually covered
Self-payPayment options
Single case agreementsAsk admissions

Read about the cost of treatment and payment options.

Check my insurance coverage

100% confidential · No commitment required

Insurance card photos (optional, speeds verification up)

Or call (801) 383-0810. See our Privacy Policy and Notice of Privacy Practices.

Blue Cross Blue ShieldAetnaCignaUnitedHealthcareAnthemHighmarkHumanaGEHAUMRHealthPartnersMagellan HealthCarelonFirst Choice HealthMedical MutualPrimero

In our clients’ words

★★★★★

My experience at Corner Canyon to put it simply, was life changing. The program gave me a structure to set a solid foundation for my life outside of treatment. The people that are involved with Corner Canyon are amazing. From the staff, to the clients, these people quickly began to feel like family. This place felt like home to me. I truly was cared for in a way that I had never been before. I can honestly say that in the 62 days I was there I didn’t have a single bad day, and that to me speaks volumes. I’m grateful to have had the experience that I did. To anyone who is looking for help – I would heavily recommend going to Corner Canyon.

sav headdenGoogle review
★★★★★

I arrived at Corner Canyon during the worst depressive episode of my life. I had no hope and felt disconnected from everything. I’m a therapist, and I had been doing all the “right” things to care for myself. But sometimes self-care is simply not enough.

Jordan BrownGoogle review
★★★★★

Corner Canyon has put together an excellent residential program. I need a comprehensive program that addressed my health and mental health with cutting edge treatment — they exceeded my expectations. With the continuum of health, mental health, and wellness services offered – they truly individualized my treatment plan. They have an excellent, well-trained staff that genuinely care. I wish I had found them 5, 10 years ago it would have saved me a lot of heart ache. I feel ALOT better than I have felt in sometime and as I continue to take care of myself, I am confident I will be an even better version of myself. Michelle Feb-Mar 2023

Angel Warrior 68Google review
★★★★★

When I came to Corner Canyon I was lost. I was 31 years old, struggling with addiction issues and my own mental health, and didn’t know which way to turn. I was very fortunate to land here. Through the help of some people who loved and cared about me, they got me in the doors of this wonderful program.

I was nervous at first, but I soon realized I was amongst peers who were feeling and going through the same things, which put me at ease. I was surrounded by staff who themselves had been through their own treatment and had such compassion and support for me and my well-being.

The Clinical team is wonderful and they are all highly trained experts. They practice many different modalities and with that they were able to get to the core of my issues to treat both my trauma, and subsequently my substance abuse. They did this with such grace, compassion, and empathy, that I always felt they had my best care in mind.

I could write forever about how this place changed my life, but the reality is that there would never be enough words. This program, it’s wonderful staff, and the people who come here make this place more than just a rehabilitation center. It’s a home. I found myself here, I found my tribe, and I was able to unlock decades worth of trauma that led me to a life I didn’t want to lead. After coming here I found the life I always wanted, and it started at Corner Canyon.

Dominique SuazoGoogle review

Three mental health facilities in Draper, Utah

Clients come to us from across Utah and the country. Admissions helps you plan your arrival.

Front entrance of the Corner Canyon residential house on Fort Street in Draper
Residential

Fort Street House

13020 S Fort St
Draper, UT 84020

Get directions
Front lawn and house at the Corner Canyon Pioneer Road residence in Draper
Residential

Pioneer Road House

1450 Pioneer Rd
Draper, UT 84020

Get directions
The bright dining room with a long table and big windows at the Corner Canyon day-treatment house on Pioneer Road
PHP & IOP

Outpatient Center

782 Pioneer Rd
Draper, UT 84020

Get directions

Talk to someone today

Calling a treatment center for the first time is hard. Our admissions team will tell you plainly whether we’re the right fit. After hours, leave a message and we’ll call you back the next morning.

In crisis? Call or text 988 or call 911.

Google reviews4.7Residential, Draper57+ reviewsDay treatment, Pioneer RdPHP and IOP
4.7 Google reviews